blog archives
Other Links eTantoco Indie Gumby Bryans Cool Jigga Wut Page Endre's Page
contact... Tell me how much my blog sucks.
Crazy is like being on the bus with Bryan without CD players. That shit is crazy.2:21:16 AM bryanbrochill: heres a serious question2:21:41 AM bryanbrochill: do you think that, given an endless amount of time, a monkey pounding on a keyboard would create romeo and juliet?2:22:17 AM Kevin: endless: (adj.) infinity2:22:17 AM Kevin: yes2:22:32 AM bryanbrochill: i think that given a literal infinite amount of time it would still never happen2:22:36 AM bryanbrochill: ever2:22:44 AM bryanbrochill: time would go on infinitely and it would never happen2:22:50 AM bryanbrochill: weird to comprehend2:22:52 AM bryanbrochill: but i think so2:23:09 AM Kevin: so its not possible for him to hit the keys exactly stroke for stroke to romeo and juliet?2:23:12 AM bryanbrochill: right2:23:15 AM bryanbrochill: i dont think so2:23:16 AM Kevin: haha that sounds stupid to even ask2:23:25 AM bryanbrochill: no its not2:23:27 AM bryanbrochill: it would never happen2:23:29 AM Kevin: but i disagree because of the word 'infinite'2:23:29 AM bryanbrochill: ever2:23:41 AM bryanbrochill: we have the same conception of the word infinite and we disagree2:24:04 AM bryanbrochill: it would never, ever, ever happen2:24:05 AM Kevin: is it possible2:24:09 AM Kevin: for a monkey2:24:19 AM Kevin: nevermind2:24:29 AM Kevin: im thinking of it more abstractly2:24:36 AM Kevin: your way makes sense2:24:36 AM bryanbrochill: we are thinking of it the same way2:24:37 AM Kevin: ill break it down2:24:40 AM bryanbrochill: and we disagree2:24:42 AM Kevin: the way I think of it was2:24:45 AM Kevin: I thought of it was2:25:09 AM Kevin: "If a random key generator was to generate a completely random key every second for infinity, would it eventually have a string equal to the play Romeo and Juliet?"2:25:37 AM bryanbrochill: ok2:25:39 AM Kevin: if it was a mokney2:25:42 AM Kevin: he might hit two keys at once2:25:45 AM bryanbrochill: is that the "wrong" way to think about it?2:25:45 AM Kevin: which complicates things2:25:48 AM bryanbrochill: hm2:26:14 AM bryanbrochill: if a random key generator did it, it would, by the very essence of its existence, ultimately HAVE to do it2:26:25 AM Kevin: yeah2:26:35 AM bryanbrochill: because it could, through infinity, type out every single possible string of letters2:26:40 AM bryanbrochill: thats a cheating cop out2:26:43 AM Kevin: ?2:26:47 AM Kevin: its a hypothetical question2:26:51 AM Kevin: you definite your assumptions2:26:56 AM Kevin: and come to a conclusion2:27:09 AM Kevin: this is so far removed from the real world by the nature of the word 'endless'2:27:11 AM bryanbrochill: its not a hypothetical at all. its a statement of fact based on what a random key generator is intrinsically2:27:42 AM bryanbrochill: a random key generator WILL, no matter what, ultimately type out every single given string of letters if given enough time2:27:52 AM bryanbrochill: no matter what2:27:53 AM Kevin: how come a monkey cant do that2:28:04 AM Kevin: wait2:28:14 AM Kevin: i didnt definite random key generator2:28:20 AM bryanbrochill: you dont have to2:28:22 AM Kevin: no i do2:28:24 AM bryanbrochill: a random key generator is what it is2:28:48 AM Kevin: every punctuation and lower and upper case letter and space and number (in english) is accounted2:28:50 AM Kevin: its about 120 characters2:28:57 AM bryanbrochill: yes2:29:02 AM Kevin: a random key generator is, for the next key, there is an EQUAL chance that ANY character can be chosen2:29:13 AM Kevin: including the previous key2:29:16 AM bryanbrochill: yea, but after it has done a combination it wont do it again2:29:19 AM Kevin: nope2:29:22 AM Kevin: it can2:29:25 AM bryanbrochill: ok then2:29:27 AM bryanbrochill: in that case2:29:28 AM Kevin: it can do aaaaaaaaaaaaa2:29:33 AM bryanbrochill: your version of the rkg will never do it2:29:35 AM Kevin: it doesnt have to do acdbef2:29:51 AM bryanbrochill: the version that will not repeat a previous combination will2:29:53 AM bryanbrochill: if given enough time2:30:07 AM Kevin: that version is not a RKG2:30:16 AM bryanbrochill: ok youre right2:30:27 AM Kevin: ok2:30:29 AM Kevin: think about it this way2:30:31 AM Kevin: im not twisting it2:30:33 AM Kevin: just elaborating2:30:42 AM Kevin: the first letter in romeo and juliet is 'A'2:30:50 AM Kevin: the chance of 'A' is 1 out of 1202:30:56 AM Kevin: the second letter is ' ' also known as space2:31:00 AM Kevin: the chance of ' ' is 1 out of 1202:31:30 AM Kevin: the chance of getting both those characters right in a row is 1 out of 144002:31:39 AM bryanbrochill: based on that definition of an RKG, the mathematical probability of romeo and juliet being produced is an impossibility2:31:44 AM Kevin: nope2:31:46 AM bryanbrochill: yes2:31:49 AM bryanbrochill: impossible2:31:52 AM bryanbrochill: mathematically speaking2:31:58 AM Kevin: ok you're stepping on my terrain now2:32:03 AM Kevin: its on like DK homeboy2:32:09 AM Kevin: there is very simple right and wrongs in pure math2:32:24 AM bryanbrochill: ok so do something for me then2:32:34 AM Kevin: romeo and juliet2:32:34 AM Kevin: has2:32:36 AM Kevin: say2:32:38 AM bryanbrochill: pretend there are only 1000 characters in randJ2:32:40 AM Kevin: 500,000 characters2:32:42 AM bryanbrochill: lol2:32:43 AM bryanbrochill: yea2:32:47 AM bryanbrochill: do the calcuations for 5000002:32:47 AM Kevin: thats a lot of characters2:32:52 AM Kevin: the chance of getting2:32:55 AM Kevin: ALL of htose RIGHT2:32:56 AM Kevin: in a ROW2:32:56 AM bryanbrochill: based on the numbers you just came up with2:33:01 AM Kevin: is2:33:07 AM bryanbrochill: is a mathematical impssibility2:33:18 AM Kevin: 1 out of 120^500002:33:29 AM Kevin: 120^50000 is NOT an infinite number2:33:34 AM bryanbrochill: it is impossible2:33:35 AM bryanbrochill: lol2:33:38 AM bryanbrochill: cmon2:33:42 AM Kevin: do you know what impossible means?2:33:44 AM bryanbrochill: yes2:33:44 AM bryanbrochill: i do2:33:46 AM Kevin: its unreasonable yeah2:33:48 AM bryanbrochill: o2:33:49 AM bryanbrochill: no2:33:51 AM Kevin: improbable2:33:55 AM bryanbrochill: impossible2:33:59 AM Kevin: impossible means2:34:02 AM Kevin: there is no possibility2:34:09 AM Kevin: meaning there is 0 chance2:34:15 AM Kevin: there is actually2:34:16 AM Kevin: 1 chance2:34:26 AM Kevin: out of 120^500002:34:30 AM bryanbrochill: do the actual calulations2:34:39 AM bryanbrochill: lol how many characters are there in romeo and juliet?2:34:44 AM Kevin: thats not the point2:34:44 AM bryanbrochill: the point is2:34:45 AM Kevin: the point is2:34:48 AM Kevin: romeo and juliet terminates2:34:55 AM Kevin: it is a limited string of characters2:34:57 AM Kevin: if you give a computer2:34:59 AM Kevin: UNLIMITED TRIES2:35:07 AM Kevin: for ALL ETERNITY2:35:11 AM Kevin: it HAS a chance2:35:15 AM bryanbrochill: hm2:35:20 AM Kevin: if you give it one roll of the die and you asked me to put money on it?2:35:25 AM Kevin: haha you kiddin me? of course its not going to hit2:35:47 AM bryanbrochill: if you want to be overly technical to the point of me basically admitting something i dont believe would ever, ever, ever, ever, ever be true2:35:53 AM bryanbrochill: sure2:35:58 AM Kevin: if you gave the eternal monkey unlimited rolls of the die for all eternity? he has a chance of hitting2:36:06 AM bryanbrochill: i think that those odds are still considered mathematically impossible2:36:06 AM Kevin: its not overly technical2:36:11 AM bryanbrochill: yes it is2:36:20 AM bryanbrochill: because we both know in our heart of hearts it would never happen2:36:22 AM Kevin: wait2:36:28 AM Kevin: say2:36:29 AM Kevin: you gave me2:36:34 AM Kevin: twenty million years2:36:38 AM Kevin: to roll this dice2:36:48 AM Kevin: and i only have a 1 out of 120^50000 chance of getting the right combination2:36:54 AM Kevin: and i got to roll like2:36:56 AM Kevin: 50 times a second2:37:04 AM Kevin: i'd say it'd never ever happen2:37:06 AM bryanbrochill: lol2:37:06 AM Kevin: theres no way it would happen2:37:18 AM bryanbrochill: youd say that?2:37:21 AM Kevin: yup2:37:23 AM bryanbrochill: ok then2:37:29 AM Kevin: if you gave me infinity years2:37:29 AM bryanbrochill: what are we in disagreement on?2:37:33 AM Kevin: i'd put all my money on it2:37:39 AM Kevin: trust me on this one2:37:42 AM bryanbrochill: but weve never had infinity years2:37:49 AM Kevin: ? you said endless in the question?2:37:49 AM bryanbrochill: infinity has never come into the equation in real life2:38:05 AM bryanbrochill: in the real world, infinity has never existed2:38:14 AM Kevin: the first thing I clarified with you2:38:19 AM Kevin: before this discussion2:38:23 AM Kevin: is that endless is and adjective for infinity2:38:31 AM bryanbrochill: yea it is2:38:40 AM bryanbrochill: in that completely theoretical scenario2:38:49 AM bryanbrochill: now we're coming out of that nonsense2:38:57 AM bryanbrochill: and looking at the real world2:39:00 AM bryanbrochill: where infinity doesnt exist2:39:03 AM Kevin: ok we agree2:39:09 AM bryanbrochill: and never has, especially in terms of allowing time for something to happen2:39:29 AM Kevin: no such thing as infinity2:39:33 AM bryanbrochill: in our conception of existence (space, time, etc.)2:39:42 AM bryanbrochill: well there may be SUCH THING2:39:46 AM bryanbrochill: it has just never happened2:40:05 AM Kevin: you're adding all these disclaimers after the fact though2:40:13 AM bryanbrochill: there may be such thing as a blue giraffe2:40:16 AM bryanbrochill: it has just never happened2:40:17 AM Kevin: i just wasted a bunch of pointless explanation2:40:22 AM bryanbrochill: lol2:40:24 AM bryanbrochill: it wasnt pointless2:40:30 AM bryanbrochill: it just happens to not have relevance to real life2:40:30 AM Kevin: it was pretty pointless2:40:46 AM Kevin: i was making a case for a situation that you didn't propose2:40:46 AM bryanbrochill: its not applicable to our situation2:40:49 AM bryanbrochill: that was my fault2:40:54 AM bryanbrochill: right2:40:54 AM bryanbrochill: yea2:41:00 AM bryanbrochill: ok so forgetting that2:41:01 AM Kevin: how is that not pointless2:41:05 AM Kevin: we already agree2:41:16 AM Kevin: give a monkey 20 million years to bash a keyboard and he'll never type romeo and juliet 2:41:20 AM bryanbrochill: it had a point in the fact that it can be used to consider a different situations2:41:34 AM bryanbrochill: just not this situation2:41:35 AM bryanbrochill: yea2:41:37 AM bryanbrochill: he never will2:41:54 AM Kevin: anywayThis kind of shit went on for like three hours Kevin killed the kitten at 3:26 AM
home